Earning and maintaining a patient’s trust is a principal requirement for healthcare professionals. It’s even more critical in our current healthcare landscape, where use of artificial intelligence (AI) in patient care is fast becoming the norm. This shift raises new challenges for compliance risk management in healthcare, especially in navigating a complex regulatory environment and ensuring AI aligns with internal policies. Without transparency, the black box nature of AI algorithms can erode patient trust when used for clinical responsibilities.
In this article, you’ll learn ways to improve algorithmic transparency. See how interpretability, ethical oversight and teamwork across fields are key to making AI fair, responsible and focused on positive patient outcomes.
Why is the AI “Black Box” Such a Problem in Healthcare?
The inner workings of complex machine learning models can function as a black box. Healthcare professionals often can’t clearly explain how the AI algorithms used in patient care systems contribute to diagnostics and arriving at clinical decisions. The lack of transparency surrounding these mechanisms can cause patients to doubt or distrust clinical decisions and outcomes when AI is involved.
This trust gap may only worsen over time as deep learning becomes more sophisticated and more opaque. That makes compliance risk management a critical factor in ensuring patient safety and minimizing potential risks. To bridge this gap, there’s an urgent need for algorithmic transparency in healthcare AI. More transparency means physicians will be able to explain AI-derived clinical outcomes and promote trust across their patient base.
What is Compliance Risk Management? The Role of AI in Modern Compliance
Compliance risk management refers to the processes healthcare organizations use to identify, assess and control risks that could lead to violations of laws, regulations or ethical standards. In healthcare, it means creating effective compliance risk management programs that align with regulatory requirements, safeguard patient information and support ethical clinical practices.
When applied to AI systems, compliance risk management focuses on building internal controls and management processes that ensure algorithms are transparent, accountable and safe to use in patient care. A well-defined risk management process strengthens this oversight and ensures compliance across both clinical and IT systems.
This includes monitoring for potential risks such as biased outputs, inaccurate diagnoses or misuse of sensitive health data, while applying structured risk assessment and risk control practices to maintain reliability and trust.
Strong compliance risk management also reduces the chance of a data breach, which can undermine patient trust and expose organizations to costly regulatory compliance penalties. By proactively addressing risks and weaving compliance into daily clinical and IT operations, healthcare leaders can create effective compliance programs that transform regulatory requirements into a framework for safe, responsible and patient-centered use of AI.
While compliance risk management establishes the guardrails, algorithmic transparency shows how the AI systems work within them.
What Does Algorithmic Transparency Mean?
Algorithmic transparency means opening the black box of AI systems. It shows what kind of data the algorithm uses, how it processes that information and which factors it weighs when providing clinical decision support. Removing the secrecy shrouding healthcare AI operations helps patients better understand and appreciate AI-assisted diagnoses and clinical decisions.
The three hallmarks of algorithmic transparency are:
- Explainability: The ability of healthcare AI to explain, in simple-to-understand terms, the reasoning behind its clinical analyses so that doctors and patients can understand the logic. This is often referred to as explainable AI (XAI).
- Interpretability: The AI’s ability to present its inner working processes, such as how it analyzes inputs vs. outputs, in a way that’s easier to grasp.Â
- Accountability: The ability to assign responsibility for AI decisions to a specific process, system or individual.
The Importance of Algorithmic Transparency in Healthcare AI
As AI tools play a growing role in diagnosing and treating patients, understanding how they work is critical. Here are some of the most important benefits of making AI systems more transparent.
It Fosters Patient-Doctor Trust
Continued trust between patients and doctors leads to better health outcomes. Conversely, lower trust levels trigger poor patient health outcomes, poor medication compliance and increased unwillingness to disclose information to physicians.
With algorithmic transparency, patients understand and appreciate both AI’s and their doctors’ input in their medical care. When physicians can clearly explain how a healthcare AI system arrived at a clinical decision, they are more able to earn and maintain patient trust.
It Helps Fix Artificial Intelligence Bias and Errors
Because interpretability is a pillar of algorithmic transparency, healthcare experts can study the internal operations of their healthcare AI and identify existing biases and errors to fix them early. Doing so helps physicians to deliver error-free clinical decisions consistently and supports broader business processes that depend on accuracy and accountability. This enhances the patient experience and boosts clinicians’ professional credibility.
It Facilitates Compliance With Pertinent Regulatory Frameworks
Algorithmic transparency helps healthcare leaders strengthen compliance risk management efforts, including meeting Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulatory requirements and other federal laws that impose strict standards for handling protected health information, even when used in AI tools.
Additionally, many states are enacting new laws to regulate the use of healthcare AI, raising the stakes for regulatory compliance programs within healthcare organizations and highlighting the need for compliance tools. For instance, California’s AB 3030 law mandates healthcare providers to disclose to patients every time they use AI tools to facilitate clinical conversations.
It Supports More Timely Clinical Decisions
With healthcare AI becoming more pervasive in precision medicine and personalized care, speed and accuracy of delivering medical care and decisions are critical. Algorithmic transparency helps physicians quickly interpret results and make faster, more informed treatment decisions when using healthcare AI.
Strategies for Implementing and Enhancing Algorithmic Transparency
Achieving algorithmic transparency isn’t an overnight endeavor. It requires strategic planning and execution in the early stages of implementing healthcare AI. Moreover, you must continuously optimize your healthcare AI to ensure it accommodates new innovations and regulations in the industry. Here are proven strategies you can implement.
Build an Ethical Framework for Your Healthcare AI
An ethical framework, supported by strong internal controls, helps keep your healthcare AI bias-free. It should address these three main types of bias that often arise in healthcare AI systems:
- Interaction bias: This describes when AI behaves abnormally because of how end users in a clinical setting utilize it. This calls for extensive training to ensure end users interact with the AI ethically and accurately.Â
- Development bias: This bias happens in the design stage when developers use biased or incomplete data to train and develop healthcare AI.Â
- Data bias: When the training data is biased towards a particular group of people, the AI may deliver the wrong results for some patients.
Prioritize Explainable AI (XAI)
XAI advances evidence-based clinical decision-making by facilitating the transparency and interpretability of all AI-based tools used in decision support systems. It promotes the accuracy of AI-derived clinical decisions and simplifies complex outcomes and processes for clinicians.
Integrate Healthcare AI With Human Oversight
The ultimate goal of healthcare AI is to support clinicians to perform their duties more efficiently, not to replace them entirely. Physicians must carefully review AI clinical decisions and suggestions before recommending them to patients. They must also openly share with patients the fact that they’re using AI in their clinical processes and seek their consent.
Foster Cross-Disciplinary Collaboration To Enhance Fair Clinical Outcomes
Implementing algorithmic transparency is a team effort involving experts in different fields, including AI, ethics, medicine and social science. Close expert collaboration advances AI fairness as healthcare AI is trained using diverse data encompassing social, ethical and biological considerations.
Schedule Regular Audits To Assess AI Performance
Bias often creeps in over time as healthcare AI processes diverse patient data. Regular internal audits and reviews, supported by audit trails, can help track changes on a routine basis. You can leverage the NIST AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF) to audit the performance, accuracy and reliability of your AI plus root out existing biases as part of your compliance risk management strategy. Documenting these reviews with clear audit trails helps reduce compliance issues and demonstrates effective compliance risk management on a regular basis. Consider sharing summaries of audit results with patients to boost their confidence in your healthcare AI.
Background Check AI Vendors To Ascertain Compliance
You may work with different tech vendors that deliver healthcare AI services. Before onboarding any third-party vendor, conduct a detailed security audit to ensure their IT and AI systems meet expected industry standards such as HIPAA or HITRUST. This helps to minimize the cybersecurity threats that are on the rise in the healthcare sector.
Keep Track of Evolving AI Regulation and Transparency Laws
Review regulations shaping the healthcare AI and adjust your system to fulfill the set standards. Some laws that should be top of mind include:
- Executive Order 14110
- ONC’s HTI-1 Final Rule
- Applicable state laws such as Utah’s AI Policy Act, California AB 3030 and the Colorado AI Act
Action Plan for Effective Compliance Risk Management
To stay ahead of regulatory changes, healthcare leaders need more than ad hoc fixes. They should create a structured action plan that ties together compliance management, the risk management process and ongoing monitoring requirements.
A strong action plan includes:
- Defining compliance requirements: Identify the international and federal laws, state regulations and internal policies that apply to your organization’s use of healthcare AI.
- Embedding compliance into business processes: Build compliance checks into everyday business processes, from vendor selection to patient care workflows. This ensures oversight happens on a regular basis, not only during audits.Â
- Conducting regular internal audits: Use audit trails and structured internal audits to verify adherence to standards. This helps detect compliance issues early and demonstrate effective compliance risk management to regulators and stakeholders.
- Developing a monitoring and response framework: Establish ongoing monitoring of AI systems for potential risks such as bias or data misuse. Pair this with a documented risk control and response process to ensure issues are corrected quickly.
- Training and communication: Provide clear training to staff on compliance tools, internal controls and the organization’s risk management process. Regular communication with patients about these safeguards also helps strengthen trust.
By following this action plan, healthcare organizations can transform compliance risk management from a reactive task into a proactive framework that supports regulatory compliance, improves patient outcomes and ensures AI systems are both safe and accountable.
Good-Bye, Black Box Challenge; Hello, Better AI-Patient Care Collaboration
Download our detailed white paper today for expert strategies on compliance risk management in healthcare AI. Learn how to strengthen internal controls, meet regulatory requirements and overcome the black box challenge for good.
